I have been wrong about coin storage in most of the directions it is possible to be wrong. I kept wheat cents in a coffee can for the better part of thirty years because that is how my grandfather kept his and it did not occur to me to improve on the man. I put a Morgan dollar in a cardboard flip that had gone soft at the corners, put the flip in a drawer, and did not look at the coin again for a decade. So when I recommend a capsule, understand that I came to it late, and by way of ruining a couple of things first.

This is the honest version of my notes on the Utron 40mm coin capsules, which means it is mostly the parts a product listing will not tell you. They hold a silver dollar. You can see both faces without putting a thumb on either one. And there is a foam washer sitting inside each capsule that does not seal anything, is not what I would call a gasket, and is the one piece of the whole arrangement I would change. That is the review in a breath. The rest of this is the why of it.

The Quick Verdict

★★★★☆ 7.8/10

The right outside size for a Morgan or a Peace dollar, and enough of them in the bag to case a whole roll in one sitting. The foam washers are the honest weak point, so look at them once a year.

Check Today's Price →

One bag, sixty capsules, seven washer sizes

Enough to case a full roll of silver dollars or a shoebox of wheat cents in an evening. Check the washer size chart on the listing against your coin before you order.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

What Comes in the Bag, Precisely

Sixty capsules, each one 40mm across the outside, with foam washers in seven listed sizes: 38mm, 33mm, 30mm, 27mm, 25mm, 20mm and 17mm. The listing says the washers let one case hold seven different coin sizes and keep a coin from moving, and that is exactly what they do. The barrel of each capsule is smooth plastic with rounded corners, and the lid is a push fit that seats down over it. It also says the cases keep a coin from rusting or getting damaged and let you see what is inside. All true as far as it goes. I will get to where it stops going.

The capsules arrive in two pieces with the washers loose in the bag, so your first hour with them is assembly, not storage. You lay a washer in the bottom half, set the coin inside the washer, and press the top half down until it sits flat. It is quiet work and the lid does not click into a lock. None of it is difficult, but you cannot pull a capsule out of the bag and drop a dollar straight in. Give yourself an evening if you have a roll to do.

One detail I appreciated, having spent thirty years in a machine shop: the corners are rounded and the finish is smooth, so there is no sharp lip anywhere near a coin edge. The number of cheap holders I have handled with a molded seam that will catch the reeding on a half dollar is a small ongoing sadness. These do not have that seam. Whether the foam washer in the bottom is seated flat before you press the lid is on you, and it is worth a look each time, because a washer pinched at one edge will hold the coin at a slight tilt.

Hands lowering a large silver coin into a coin capsule on a felt mat, with a loupe beside it

How I've Used Them

My granddaughter Maddie is nine and has been coming by on Saturdays since the spring to learn the hobby. She has a small pile of her own now, mostly wheat cents and a couple of worn Mercuries that turned up in my desk drawer, and the two of us sat at the kitchen table with the bag of Utron capsules between us and sorted for the better part of two hours. She had the assembly down by the third one. That is a fair test of a coin holder, honestly. If a nine year old can seat a washer and press a lid without pinching a coin, the design is doing its job.

My own work happens on a desk in the spare bedroom, with a lamp, a felt pad, a loupe and a small fireproof box in the closet for the things I would rather not leave out. The capsules live in a shallow tray on that desk now. Before this bag I was using cardboard flips for the dollars and I have mostly stopped, with one exception I will describe further down. The flips were fine for holding a coin. They were not fine for looking at one, and looking at them is most of why I am still in this hobby at sixty three.

The first thing I did with a spare capsule was drop it on the garage floor from about waist height, lid down, to see what would happen. The lid stayed on. The seam took a scuff and there is a dull spot on that corner now. That is a fair result for a plastic case. I have owned holders that popped open from a fall off a table, and a silver dollar on a concrete floor is a bad afternoon that you do not forget.

Six months in, nothing in the tray has gone cloudy, no washer has gone sticky, and the only capsule that looks used is the one I dropped. I go through the dollars once a month under the lamp with the loupe, both faces and the edge, and I have not found anything new on them. That is not proof of anything. It is six months and a dry house in Ohio.

I took the tray to the club meeting once, mostly to see whether the older fellows would say anything. Two of them asked where the capsules came from and one told me he had been using the same style for years. Nobody told me I was doing it wrong, which around that room counts as high praise.

The Fit Question Nobody Explains Up Front

Here is the part I would want somebody to tell me before I ordered. The sizes on the washers are washer sizes, not coin sizes, and the listing does not spell out the inner diameter you will actually get. That distinction matters more than it sounds. Assume the number is the hole and you will order for a coin that does not fit. Assume it is the outside of the ring and you will order something too small. I measured mine with a pair of calipers I have had since the shop. You should measure too, before you buy a bag of sixty.

A Morgan dollar is 38.1mm across and a Peace dollar is the same. The 38mm washer takes them with the foam compressing just enough to hold without forcing, and that is the fit that matters most to me. I would call it good. An Eisenhower dollar is also 38.1mm, so the same washer handles those. The 30mm washer is the one people reach for with a half dollar, and there I would check your own coin with a caliper first, because a half dollar runs a hair over 30mm and a ring that is snug on the bench becomes a wrestling match when you have a coin in your fingers and a loupe at your eye.

The small end of the range is the other thing to know. A wheat cent is 19mm and sits in the 20mm washer with a little room to spare. The 17mm washer is for the smallest coins and it is tight on a dime, so check before you commit a whole roll of them. And here is the limit nobody mentions. The case stays 40mm no matter which washer goes inside it. A cent in a 40mm capsule looks like a pea in a coffee cup, and if you are casing a hundred pennies you will use a great deal of shelf for not much coin. That is not a flaw exactly. It is what a one size case is.

The practical version: measure the coin, match it to the washer, and buy one bag to try before you buy three. Sixty is enough to find out whether you like the system. I did the roll of dollars first, found the fit good, and then went back and did the cents knowing full well they would look a little lost in there.

The Foam Washer Is the Part I'd Think About

A foam ring is not a gasket. It does not seal. Air comes in around it and moisture comes in with the air, and no amount of pressing the lid down changes that. If you live where the summers are wet, a capsule is a way to keep your hands off a coin, not a way to keep the weather off it. Put a desiccant in whatever box you store the tray in and change it when it needs changing. That is true of every plastic holder I have used, and it is worth saying out loud because the word gasket shows up in listings and it makes people relax.

The other thing is that the listing does not say what the foam is made of. That bothers me more than the seal does. Soft foams get their softness from plasticizers, and soft plasticizers are the same family of trouble as the PVC flips everyone warns you about. I am not telling you this foam will damage a coin. I am telling you that I do not know, and the listing does not say, and a man who has pulled a green haze off a silver dollar once does not take that on faith a second time.

So I split it. The ordinary coins, the common Morgans, the wheat cents, the pocket finds, go into the Utron capsules and I do not think about them again. The one coin I would call a key date stays in an inert holder from a company that tells you what the plastic is made of. That is not a knock on these. It is knowing what a general purpose case is for. Foam also compresses over the years and loses its grip, so open a capsule once a year, look at the ring, and swap it out if it has gone flat or stiff.

The 38mm washer takes a silver dollar with no play at all. The foam ring is the part nobody explains, and it is the part I would keep an eye on.
An older man and a young girl sorting coins into small round cases at a kitchen table

What the Plastic Will and Won't Do

The plastic is not listed as UV treated, so do not leave the tray on a windowsill and expect the cases or the coins to be untouched in five years. Mine live in a box in the closet and come out to be looked at, which is the entire point of a case you can see through. You look at the coin, you put it back, you close the lid.

The outside diameter is 40mm, and that is larger than the cut slots in a standard dollar box. If you already own a box built for cardboard flips, these will not drop into it. I ended up with a shallow tray and a lidded tub, which works fine but was not the plan. Check what you are going to store them in before you order sixty of anything, because sixty of anything takes up more room than you think it will.

The push fit lid is the last honest note. It holds, and it held through a drop, but it does not lock and it does not have a thread. If you carry a capsule loose in a coat pocket, do not. In a tray on a desk, nothing has moved in six months. That is the use these were built for and it is the use I would keep them to.

Cleaning, since somebody always asks. A dry microfiber cloth and nothing else. No solvents, no plastic polish, nothing abrasive near a coin case. If a case gets hazy, replace it. They are not precious, and a hazy case is a case you will stop looking through, which defeats the whole arrangement.

What I Liked

  • Sixty in the bag, enough to case a full roll of dollars or a shoebox of cents in one evening
  • The 38mm washer holds a Morgan or a Peace dollar with no play
  • Seven washer sizes cover the range from a dime up to a silver dollar
  • Rounded corners and a smooth finish, with no molded seam to catch a coin edge
  • You can read both faces through the case without touching the metal
  • Plenty of them in the bag, so the ordinary coins get cased and the better holders are saved for key dates

Where It Falls Short

  • The foam washers are the weak link, and the listing does not say what they are made of
  • Not airtight, and there is no desiccant in the bag, so humidity still gets in
  • The listed washer sizes are not coin sizes, so you need calipers before you order
  • A 40mm case will not fit the cut slots in a standard dollar box
  • Small coins swim in a large case, which wastes shelf space
  • Push fit lid rather than a lock, and a drop will scuff the seam

Who This Is For

This is for the person with a roll of ordinary silver dollars in a tube and no way to look at them, or a coffee can of wheat cents and a grandchild who wants to see them. It is for the collector on a budget who would rather case forty coins in something decent than case four in something perfect. It is for a beginner, and I mean that plainly, because Maddie learned the assembly in three tries and no longer needs me standing over her shoulder. A holder a child can use without pinching a coin is a good holder to learn on.

Who Should Skip It

Skip it if you have a key date or a coin in high grade that you intend to keep for the long haul. Spend the money on an inert holder and a box that seals, and put the rest toward a better loupe. Skip it if your storage is a dollar box with cut slots, because these will not fit and you will be buying a tub instead. Skip it if you want a case sized to the coin, because a cent in a 40mm case looks silly and there is no way around that. And skip it if airtight is the requirement. A foam ring was never going to make a plastic case airtight, and this one does not.

Right size for the dollars, honest about the washers

Sixty capsules and seven washer sizes, enough for a roll of Morgans or a pile of wheat cents. Measure a coin first, then check today's price on the listing.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →